Hello dear
Welcome To Casa Mezcal Reserva
Casa Mezcal Reserva is a captivating dining destination located in Penn Yan, NY, celebrated for its authentic Mexican cuisine and vibrant atmosphere. The menu features a delectable array of traditional dishes, from flavorful chicken tacos and hearty carne asada to tantalizing queso dips. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and the warm, attentive service that creates a welcoming dining experience. Signature dishes such as the chimichanga and carnitas have garnered loyal patrons who return for the exceptional food and friendly ambiance. With an impressive drink selection and daily specials, Casa Mezcal Reserva promises a memorable culinary journey every visit.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Queso
US$6.89Appetizer Quesadilla
US$12.69El Maistro Vicente
La Leticia
La Chave Mezcaliza
Camilaberry Mezcalita
Santa Victoria Mezcal
Quesadilla Rellena
US$3.00Street Chori Fries
US$9.99 About
Casa Mezcal Reserva
Welcome to Casa Mezcal Reserva, a culinary gem located at 104 Liberty St, Penn Yan, NY. A community favorite, this vibrant restaurant has carved a niche for itself as a go-to destination for authentic Mexican cuisine. Boasting an impressive menu packed with tantalizing dishes, Casa Mezcal Reserva masterfully marries traditional flavors with a contemporary dining experience.
As you step inside, the warm ambiance invites you to indulge. Diners rave about the Queso dip at just $6.89, which stands out for its mild, creamy texture—unlike anything you’ve tasted before. For those seeking a taste of the sea, the Mariscada, priced at $17.99, promises a delightful mix of seafood that transports you straight to the shores of Mexico.
Fans of poultry won't want to miss the Mole for $12.99, a dish that perfectly balances rich flavors. Reviewers have noted the impressive portion sizes, ensuring that you won't leave Casa Mezcal hungry. One customer remarked they enjoyed their meal so much that they returned multiple nights in a row. This kind of enthusiasm isn’t common and speaks volumes about the quality and taste that permeate every dish.
Highlights also include the well-loved Beef and Chicken Fajitas and the mouthwatering Chimichanga with Beef Adobo. The generous servings allow you to savor each bite, with many patrons commenting on the exceptional service. Friendly and attentive staff enhance the dining experience, creating a lively atmosphere where every visit feels like a special occasion.
Pair your meal with one of their excellent drinks for a complete experience; while the drinks may lean a bit pricier, the unforgettable flavors of Casa Mezcal’s meals justify the splurge. As one diner aptly put it, the Margarita and Steak Quesadillas complement the eclectic experience, making it a must to return for more. The place was buzzing on every visit, showcasing its popularity among locals and visitors alike.
Casa Mezcal Reserva is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary sanctuary where flavors come alive and memories are made. Whether you’re new to Mexican food or a seasoned aficionado, you owe it to yourself to experience this vibrant hub of deliciousness. Prepare to be delighted as you navigate through the thoughtfully crafted menu and enjoy what many are calling the best Mexican cuisine in the Penn Yan area.
So, gather your friends or family and head to Casa Mezcal Reserva—you won't just be having dinner; you'll be indulging in a flavorful celebration!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ WOW. just... wow. tastiest chicken tacos I've ever had. The queso dip was incredible and mild, without jalapeno skins. Our waitress was perfect - attentive, thoughtful, prompt and had a good memory. Dinner specials are nice and reasonably prices. Drinks menu is a bit pricier (5.50 beer, 8 wine glass) but if you get a more budget friendly meal, you can easily add drinks to your ticket without breaking the bank. ”
“ Steak Quesadillas and steak fajitas were awesome! So was the margarita. Food servings are large. Took half my meal home. Waiter was awesome as well! Our favorite Mexican restaurant in the area. ”
“ 20250520 I ordered the beef and chicken fajita with 2 flour tortilla. My to-go order was missing the tortilla, but good thing... I didn't need the carbs. The meal was delicious, but unfortunately, it was cold by the time I got the hotel, which was only a few mins away. The presentation was great, and i like like tortilla bowl with the refried beans, delicious! Unfortunately, my finicky pups are not interested in the beef or chicken fajita. I also have root beer from Finger Lakes . I got a bottle to try. Going to find where it's sold! I would come back again. I want to try the chicken tortilla soup and carne asada. Saw pics of these 2 dishes on the Google maps reviews. They looked delicious! The employees are very polite and helpful. It's refreshing since many businesses lack customer service nowadays. ”
“ We were in town for business then vacation with friends. We came to Casa Mezcal on the first night... and ended up coming each night after for a total of five in a row! The carnitas are the best I’ve had, the burritos were delicious as were the enchiladas. The chimichanga with beef adobo also delicious. Excellent drinks. The staff were all so friendly and the place was packed by the time we left each evening. Cannot wait to come back next year!!!! ”
“ Went twice (on back to back days). The service, the food, the drinks are phenomenal! Everyone is so friendly and the food is amazing. ”
“ I am with OEG working on a job. The guys and I eat here every day for dinner and most days lunch as well. The food is amazing. We have had everything on the menu. The service is always 5 star. We will miss this place when the job is finished. I want to thank everyone who takes care of us. ”
“ The food and margaritas at this restaurant are delicious. I came for lunch with a group of 7 and the staff promptly put together a table for us. Our server Dayna took good care of us and was able to help with any questions we had. Everything tasted so fresh. The chips and salsa was the perfect snack while waiting for drinks, the fruit juices in the margaritas tasted so fresh, and every one of our meals was prepared well and as ordered. This place had us wishing we were staying in the area for longer so we could've come back again! ”
“ Great spot for a hearty Mexican meal! The staff was super friendly and impressively quick—especially considering how packed it was. We sat at the bar, which meant no wait for a table (highly recommend if you're in a rush). Their “medium” frozen margarita is huge, and they definitely didn’t skimp on the pour! I ordered the steak and cheese burrito—grilled steak with onions and bell peppers, wrapped in a warm flour tortilla with plenty of cheese—and it really hit the spot. The beans and rice on the side were solid too. The atmosphere is lively and energetic, and it’s clear this place is popular with the locals. I’ll definitely be coming back next time I’m in town! ”